Pickering Town: Alfie Burnett; Jamie Thornton (Harry Dawson), Ben Leyland, Wayne Brooksby, Connor Avison, Blake Drury, Nathan Dyer, Harry Lovick, Harry Jessup (Sam Calvert), George Brown (Kieran Stares), Joe Wood (Mathew Garbutt). Sub. (not used): Ronnie Kelly.
Knaresborough Town: Tommy Brown; Aaron Pilkington, Dan Burns, James Beaston, Ryan Gothard (Alex Ingham); Jack Lazenby, Luis Penny-Larter, Brad Walker, Lewis Stephens (Fedel Ross-Lang), Harry Lee (Dom Creamer); Adam Priestley. Subs. (not used): Sam Cook, Simon Parkes.
After a very shaky start and a disappointing first half in general, Knaresborough Town settled after the break and came close to taking full points from their visit to Pickering Town on Tuesday evening.
A third minute break down the right saw Nathan Dyer with oceans of space to allow him to cross for Joe Wood to have an easy tap in to open the home account.
Knaresborough soon pressed back themselves and were awarded a 10th minute penalty when Adam Priestley was tripped, but the forward slammed the kick over the crossbar.
Jack Lazenby shot over, before another Pickering press allowed space for Dyer to run through and finish the scoring himself to make it 2-0 in the 29th minute.
Harry Jessup was next to benefit from slack passing at the back of the Knaresborough defence, but this time, Tommy Brown was alert and saved well.
The half ended with Harry Lovick firing over for another home chance and Knaresborough were thankful for the interval to allow them to re-group.
Dom Creamer had entered the game before the break and Alex Ingham arrived after it and became an instant hit when he chased down a long pass from Jack Lazenby and, having beaten his marker managed to prod into the corner of the net in the 47th minute.
Brown saved again from Wood, but then Knaresborough drew level in the 57th minute when Creamer chased a through ball and Alfie Burnett could only partially clear and allow Priestley to loft over the defence and into the top corner.
Priestley then headed Creamer’s centre into the side-netting and shot narrowly wide following Ingham’s pass as Knaresborough latched on to uncertainty in the home ranks.
The reward arrived in the 74th minute when Ingham headed home Lazenby’s left wing corner at the back post to put his side ahead for the first time.
In the 81st minute, all the good work was undone as James Beaston played a back pass to Brown whose clearance was charged down by Kieran Stares and the ball flew into the unguarded net.
Both sides continued to press for a winner, with Sam Calvert firing over for Pickering and Fedel Ross-Lang wide for Knaresborough before a late Dan Burns header was tipped over by Burnett as time ran out.